What questions should CLTs be asking when assessing a site for development? We share our top tips.
Last month the Forest CLT team met with Colin Archer, Associate Advisor at Community Led Housing London, who walked us through the key considerations and steps behind building an appraisal for a new development. It was a really helpful session, with lots to take away and think about, and we wanted to share some of our key learnings.
Here are the top 10 questions we’ll be asking when assessing future schemes.
- What tenures will you be offering on the housing? This could be a mixture of rent (social, affordable, London affordable, London Living, and market rate) and ownership (shared, fixed equity, shared equity, or outright sale). This can impact the scheme’s affordability, with some units retained for outright sale to unlock the funding needed.
- How will you be defining affordability? For example, the Greater London Authority (GLA) have rules on no affordable housing offered to households earning more than £90,000. What is your threshold, and how are you calculating this to make sure it’s appropriate for your local area?
- Who are your stakeholders? These will include grant providers, funders, planners, landowners – how will you identify and engage them in the appraisal development and secure their support?
- Is it fundable? Does it meet the grant funders’ requirements, and will cash be available throughout the development period (making up on any shortfall from the grant)?
- Are you using up to date cost estimates? Construction costs have sky-rocketed in the past few years (i.e., from under £2,000 per m2 to over £3,000) so will have a big impact on the appraisal.
- Is it buildable? Is it affordable (and does it maximise space for dwellings vs other uses), and rational / realistic for the site? Does it meet planning requirements?
- What assumptions do you need to make? It’s OK to make assumptions as a 30-year appraisal will need some flexibility, but how can you use standard assumptions for funding, maintenance, management etc to help ensure you build a realistic appraisal?
- Who will be supporting the build? You might want to consider both a project management and a development manager, as some projects require a registered partner from a housing association.
- Once built, will the scheme be maintainable? Have you considered the longer-term cost and resource requirements involved?
- What are your key performance indicators? And how will you track and report on them to demonstrate success?
If you’d like to learn more about the proposals that Forest CLT has developed so far, you can find them on our website here. We’re proactively looking for new opportunities for sites to develop, so if you have any suggestions or contacts to put us in touch with, please let us know at info@forestclt.org !